io.github.OtherVibes/mcp-as-a-judge
MCP-as-a-Judge
Is the io.github.OtherVibes/mcp-as-a-judge MCP server down? No. Installed with mcp<2, it started and listed its tools on 2026-11-06.
MCP as a Judge: a behavioral MCP that strengthens AI coding assistants via explicit LLM evaluations
needs mcp<2 probed 2026-11-14 · unchanged since 2026-11-06
A plain install of the package stops at the import below. These tool definitions are from a second install with mcp<2, started in a container with the network off, on 2026-11-06.
MCP error -32000: Connection closed ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'mcp.server.fastmcp'. This is mcp 2.x, where FastMCP was renamed to MCPServer (from mcp
- Run it
- uvx --with 'mcp<2' mcp-as-a-judge@0.3.20 (stdio, probed in a container with the network off)
- Host
- pypi.org
- Reports itself as
- MCP-as-a-Judge 1.30.0
- Capabilities
- experimental, prompts, resources, tools
- Repository
- https://github.com/OtherVibes/mcp-as-a-judge
- Registry
- active, updated 2025-09-20 · registry entry
- Changes
- 2 recorded, reachable in 0 of them. A row is added when the result, the tool count or the cost changes.
Most expensive tools
Estimates with the o200k_base tokenizer.
| Tool | o200k estimate | Share of this server |
|---|---|---|
| judge_coding_plan | 6 260 | 20 % |
| judge_code_change | 6 127 | 20 % |
| set_coding_task | 6 094 | 20 % |
| judge_testing_implementation | 6 088 | 20 % |
| judge_coding_task_completion | 5 567 | 18 % |
Compare this server with others.
More servers
Other registry entries on pypi.org, the ones next to this name; all of them.
- Raptor Studio io.github.OpenPowerShift/raptor-studio · alive
- io.github.Optisol-Business/db-metadata-extractor-mcp · needs mcp<2
- io.github.OraclesTech/guardian-mcp · crashed on start
- osu! MCP io.github.Osyanne/osu-mcp · crashed on start
- Bosco Labs data io.github.PB7-debug/bosco-labs-data · alive
- io.github.PCfVW/mcp-arangodb-async · crashed on start
- PEARSim io.github.PEAR-power/pear-sim · crashed on start
- Sarup io.github.PHUICMT/sarup · alive
Servers that mention judge.
- Court Rules app.courtrules/court-rules · needs auth
- Earlywire — Marketing & Growth Intelligence com.barisasa.earlywire/wire · alive
- California Justice Watch com.cajusticewatch/cajusticewatch · alive
- CompletionKit com.completionkit/evals · alive
- com.fahaliai/fahali · needs auth
- KnowJudges com.knowjudges/knowjudges · alive
- com.memfleet/memfleet · needs auth
- Mentionry com.mentionry/mentionry · alive
History
We add a row when the result changes. A server with no change keeps its last row.
| Probed | Result | Init | Tools | Claude | o200k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-11-06 08:40 | needs mcp<2 | 7.7 s | 8 | 51k | 31k |
| 2026-10-16 06:27 | crashed on start |
Badge for the README
The result of the latest probe, the tool count and the token cost. The feed has an entry for every probe that changed them.
A mail when this server changes
Stops answering, comes back, tool set or cost changes. One confirmation mail first, a stop link in every mail.
For the publisher
- The package imports FastMCP from mcp.server.fastmcp. mcp 2.0, the Python SDK of 28 July 2026, renamed FastMCP to MCPServer, and the package asks for mcp with no upper bound, so a plain install (uvx, pip) gets mcp 2.x and the server stops at the import. Installed with mcp<2, it starts and lists its tools. The fix for the publisher: pin mcp<2 in the dependencies, for example mcp>=1.2,<2, and publish a new version, or move to MCPServer as the SDK's migration guide says. Until then, run it with uvx --with 'mcp<2'.
The cause and the fix, with the code before and after: ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'mcp.server.fastmcp'